As stated in the video, the overarching failure in vietnam was that the us viewed the struggle through the wrong lens, seeing it as a key part of the cold war rather than as the trying to win such a war with a government viewed as corrupt and seen as a “colonialist american puppet” was futile yet would. Vietnam war: who was right about what went wrong – and why it matters in afghanistan september 13, 2017 913pm edt secretary of state dean rusk faced with this prospect, the reasoning went, the north vietnamese communists would sue for peace on american terms arthur schlesinger jr in 1951 wikipedia. Theology, just war ethics, the influence of fellow jesuits, summer internships at america, the march against the pentagon led by intellectuals like war, ken burns's “the vietnam war,” written by geoffrey c ward as a 10-part documentary series totaling 18 hours, tries to answer what went wrong and what. They further misread the character of the vietnam war in a manner that promoted conventional us military responses to what was still--in 1965--essentially a revolutionary political challenge in doing all of these things, american decison makers committed to an exceedingly difficult conflict a measure of us military power. The united states had funded france's military failure to the tune of about $25 billion the second war was a civil war between the two zones created at geneva : north vietnam, governed by vietnamese communists, and south vietnam, backed by american aid and, eventually, by american troops. Is the patriotic thing to support your country when it's right, and more importantly, when it's wrong or is it to point out when america's actions don't live up to its stated values as the american war in vietnam dragged on, the gulf between these two positions widened it became harder for americans in each. John mccain has appeared to criticise donald trump by saying it was wrong for wealthy americans to avoid being drafted into the us army during the vietnam war one aspect of the conflict, by the way, that i will never ever countenance is that we drafted the lowest income level of america and the. America's involvement in vietnam, that was to lead to a full-scale military attack on north vietnam, was all part of the cold war scenario that had enveloped world politics in the 1950's, john foster dulles, us secretary of state, had formulated the domino theory this stated that if one country fell to communism, then its.
From american histories, you would think the primary feature of the vietnam war was combat it wasn't suffering was its main characteristic to stay on top of important articles like these, sign up to receive the latest updates from tomdispatchcom here. The new series on the vietnam war, and the mysteries of historical resonance in roughly the center of this view of the pee dee river in south carolina is the snow's island national historic landmark these are the swamplands where the american forces led by francis marion applied guerrilla tactics. This question originally appeared on quora, the best answer to any question ask a question, get a great answer learn from experts and access insider knowledge you can follow quora on twitter, facebook, and google plus answer by tony morse, managing partner, spatial analysis group. Two things went wrong: the first was the lbj administration's attempt to backpeddle the war, making promises of victory that we couldn't keep tet was a huge surprise to the american press - contradicted everything they had been told can't really blame the military turns out you can't rely on your enemy to.
Ken burns and lynn novick talk about episode 3 of the vietnam war and the rarely told stories of the vietnamese soldiers who fought i mean i think that colonial analysis of america's behavior in vietnam is not necessarily wrong, but it's incomplete in a way that had not occurred to me before this movie. The vietnam war began in the decade before, but the conflict, and especially us involvement, escalated in the 1960s for the first time, americans witnessed the horrors of war, played out on television screens in their living rooms this week's episode of the sixties explores the war and its impact on. In national 5 history read how the americans were unable to defeat the vietcong, and about american opposition to the war.
It was about the united states worried about the spread of communism you see, vietnam had historically been a french colony, but had been occvupied by the khmer, french, and americans and they emerged victorious every time the us invaded north vietnam to stop the rise of communism via the 'domino effect'. The worst case of selective veteran testimony is also, consequently, perhaps the low point of the documentary merrill mcpeak, an air force pilot during the war, praises the plucky north vietnamese and states point blank that america was on the wrong side of the fight this represents but one example of.
The origins of american involvement in vietnam date back to the end of the second world war, when the vietnamese were struggling against the continued french colonial presence in their country ho chi minh, the leader of the viet minh (vietnamese independence league) and the founder of vietnam's communist party,. Though he had spent a good deal of time as a reporter in vietnam during the early 1960s, halberstam took the same american-centered, washington- centered, history-from-the top approach as mcmaster and dozens of other writers among the more recent examples is frederic logevall's choosing war:.
Did the united states win or lose the vietnam war we are taught that it was a resounding loss for america, one that proves that intervening in the affairs of other nations is usually misguided the truth is that our military won the war, but our politicians lost it the communists in north vietnam actually. The story of the vietnam war given here is one many historians would recognize and agree with but some of the united states feared the global spread of communism, but the doctrine of containment made it difficult to see nations as distinct, as places with different cultures, different problems, different histories in this. More than 58,000 americans were killed along with more than 4 million vietnamese, laotians, and cambodians so what exactly do indeed, it became an article of faith that the most shameful aspect of the vietnam war was the nation's failure to embrace and honor its returning soldiers of course, there. The histories of us military involvements in vietnam and afghanistan should serve as warnings to future presidents who might be tempted to again jump onto the treadmill of perpetual war maine news, sports, politics, election results, and obituaries from the bangor daily news.